The contribution of a reproduction paper is based on analyses of plus in insights into current methods and problems—plus the additional certainty that is sold with validating past outcomes.

The contribution of a reproduction paper is based on analyses of plus in insights into current methods and problems—plus the additional certainty that is sold with validating past outcomes.

  1. Relevance: Is it paper highly relevant to COLING?
  2. Readability/clarity: could be the paper well-structured and well-written?
  3. Data/code access: could be the data/code (as appropriate) open to the study community or perhaps is here a reason that is compelling why this isn’t feasible? Continue reading →